Two Statements
STATEMENT OF DANIEL FROST
I want to begin by saying I am calm. I know how that sounds. Detectives underline that word. But I have always been calm, and it is not a crime.
On the night of November third, I drove to the lake house with my wife, Anna, and her friend Julian Marsh. We arrived at six. Anna lit the fire. Julian opened a bottle of wine he had brought himself, with his own corkscrew, from his own coat pocket. I noticed that. A man who plans for wine is a man who plans.
At nine, Anna said she wanted to see the lake. At ten, she hadn't come back. I went down to the water. She was in the shallows, face down, her red scarf floating beside her like a flower.
I will not describe the next minute. I will tell you only that I ran up the path to the house, and Julian was sitting at the kitchen table.
He had made tea. Two cups. He pushed one toward me and said, "Take your time."
My wife was in the lake, and he said, take your time.
He did not ask where Anna was. He did not ask what was wrong. He asked if I took sugar. Then he took out a small notebook, wrote something down, and watched my face the way you watch a pot that is about to boil.
I am not the strange one here. I cried. I screamed. I did all the things a person does. Julian did none of them, and when the paramedics came, I saw him smile at the floor, just once, when he thought nobody was looking.
I have told you everything. The man you should be afraid of is the one who stayed calm.
STATEMENT OF JULIAN MARSH
I want to begin by saying I am calm. I know how that sounds. Detectives underline that word. But I have always been calm, and it is not a crime.
On the night of November third, I drove to the lake house with my friend Anna and her husband, Daniel. We arrived at six. Anna lit the fire. I opened the wine, and Daniel took out his own corkscrew from inside his coat, because he did not trust mine. I noticed that. A man who plans for wine is a man who plans.
At nine, Anna said she wanted to see the lake. At 9:40, I went into the kitchen and found the kettle already hot. Daniel was standing beside it with two cups. He had been standing there for some time. I could tell by the dry tea bags.
I asked where Anna was. He said, "Out for her walk." He said it so smoothly, like a line he had practised.
At ten, he finally went down to the lake. When he came back, he was shaking, and he was crying, and every tear arrived exactly when it should. I have seen real grief. It is ugly and it is late. His was beautiful and on time.
He kept telling the paramedics about her red scarf, how it floated like a flower. Anna was not wearing a scarf that night. It was in the car. I know, because I put it there. Nobody has told him she was wearing a scarf. Nobody had to.
He says I smiled. I did not smile. If my face moved, it was because I was looking at his hands, which were perfectly steady, and trying to understand how a man's hands can be that still.
He says I wrote in a notebook. I did. I wrote the time, 9:40, the kettle, the dry tea bags. I am a careful man. Someone had to be.
I have told you everything. The man you should be afraid of is the one who cried too well.
A NOTE FROM THE PERSON WHO TYPED THESE STATEMENTS
The two men have never been in a room together since that night. They were interviewed in identical rooms, at the same hour, on opposite sides of the same building.
Their statements agree on nearly everything: the fire, the wine, the corkscrew, the tea, the notebook, the smile at the floor. They disagree only on one point, which is who made the tea.
The lake was searched. The red scarf was found in the shallows. The scarf was in the car, Julian says. The scarf was in the water, Daniel says. The police say both are true, because there were two scarves, and neither man has explained why.
When each interview ended, each man said the same thing to me at the door, quietly, with the same small smile: "You've been very kind. Would you like some tea?"
I said no to both.
I am writing this at my desk now, very late. I have a cup beside me, and it is warm. I do not remember making it.
I do not remember making it.

Comments
Post a Comment